Advocating for You in Court and Beyond Team Up With Us

Insurance Bad Faith and Failure to Defend Lawyers in Wichita, Kansas

Your liability insurer is supposed to protect you. When it refuses to defend you, or refuses a reasonable settlement offer and leaves you facing a judgment above your policy limits, you may have a claim against your own insurer. In Kansas, you do not have to prove the insurer acted in bad faith. Negligence in defending or settling the claim against you is enough. Graybill & Hazlewood represents policyholders, and people injured by them, in these cases throughout Kansas. Call (316) 266-4058. Lawyers: we accept referrals and serve as co-counsel on bad faith and excess judgment cases.

Cases We Handle

  • Negligent or bad-faith failure to settle within policy limits, leaving the policyholder exposed to an excess judgment.

  • Refusal to defend a lawsuit against the policyholder.

  • Wrongful denial of liability coverage.

  • Recovering excess judgments from the responsible liability insurer.

Denied property claim? See our hail, fire, and commercial property pages.

Results

  • $3 million recovered on a wrongful denial of liability coverage to a driver who caused a collision

  • $861,777 judgment against our client erased. Her insurer refused to defend or cover her. We sued the insurer on a theory no Kansas court had decided, and it paid the injured plaintiff $250,000 in a compromise that satisfied the judgment, reimbursed our client’s defense costs and paid her attorney fees. The court found our work increased her net worth by more than $900,000.

  • More than $400,000 excess judgment against a policyholder satisfied in full after a bad faith claim against her auto insurer; our client paid nothing

  • $250,000 paid by a liability insurer after remand in Nungesser v. Bryant, 283 Kan. 550 (2007)

See more results

Amounts are gross recoveries before fees and costs. Every case depends on its own facts and law. Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

What Kansas Law Requires of a Liability Insurer

These rules come from Kansas appellate decisions. They are not our cases.

  • Good faith and due care. In defending and settling claims against its policyholder, a liability insurer must act in good faith and without negligence. Either failure is enough. Bollinger v. Nuss, 202 Kan. 326 (1969).

  • Equal consideration. The insurer must give the policyholder's interests at least as much weight as its own, and evaluate the claim as though it alone would pay the entire judgment.

  • Liability above policy limits. Kansas does not recognize a separate tort of bad faith, but an insurer that breaches these duties is liable for the policyholder's full loss, even above policy limits. Spencer v. Aetna Life & Casualty Insurance Co., 227 Kan. 914 (1980).

  • A late offer is not a cure. An insurer cannot undo earlier negligence or bad faith by offering its policy limits after suit is filed. Interest can run on the entire judgment, and in some cases the insurer must also pay attorney fees. Gruber v. Estate of Marshall, 59 Kan. App. 2d 297 (2021).

Kansas Supreme Court Cases

In Nungesser v. Bryant, 283 Kan. 550 (2007), the Kansas Supreme Court held that a policyholder cannot sue a liability insurer for failure to settle until the policyholder's liability is decided. After remand, the insurer paid $250,000.

In Lee Builders v. Farm Bureau, 281 Kan. 844 (2006), we won a ruling that unintended, unexpected property damage caused by faulty workmanship can be a covered "occurrence" under a contractor's liability policy.

In Moore v. St. Paul Fire & Mercury Insurance Co., 269 Kan. 272 (2000), argued by Jacob S. Graybill before he co-founded our firm, the court held that an insurer ordered to pay its policyholder's attorney fees must also pay the reasonable cost of proving those fees.

If You've Been Sued and Your Insurer Won't Help

  1. Send the lawsuit and every settlement demand to your insurer right away, in writing.

  2. Keep every letter from your insurer, including any denial or "reservation of rights."

  3. Don't ignore the lawsuit. Deadlines to respond are short.

  4. Call us. We can review whether the insurer owes you a defense and how to protect you from an excess judgment. If no lawyer is defending you, we can step in to protect you now while we pursue your insurer.

Bad Faith FAQs

What is insurance bad faith in Kansas?

Kansas does not recognize a separate lawsuit, or tort, for insurance bad faith. But a liability insurer that defends and settles claims against you must act in good faith and without negligence. If it does not, for example by refusing a reasonable settlement within policy limits or by failing to defend you, it can be liable for your full loss, including the part of a judgment above your policy limits. A denied claim under your own property policy is different. Those remedies come through the policy, interest, and laws that can make the insurer pay your attorney fees.

I was injured by someone whose insurer refused to settle. Can you help?

Often, yes. In some cases, the injured person can pursue the insurer after a judgment against its policyholder, by garnishment or by an assignment of the policyholder's claim. Call us to talk through your situation.

Do you work with other lawyers on these cases?

Yes. We work with lawyers across Kansas and can take the whole case or serve as co-counsel. Any fee division is disclosed to the client and follows Kansas ethics rules.

What It Costs

Most cases are handled on a contingency fee. That means our fee is a share of what we recover. If there is no recovery, you owe no attorney fee. You may still owe some case costs; your written fee agreement explains which ones, and we'll go over it with you before you sign. In some cases, Kansas law allows a court to order an insurer that refused to pay without just cause or excuse to also pay its policyholder's reasonable attorney fees.

Related Insurance Claims

Talk to a Lawyer

Call (316) 266-4058 for a free review of your claim. A lawyer will talk with you, and we'll tell you plainly whether we can help. We represent clients throughout Kansas and can talk by phone.

Written and reviewed by N. Russell Hazlewood, Kansas attorney since 1998. Last reviewed November 18, 2026.

Sued and Your Insurer Won't Help? Get a Free Case Review.

Get a Free Case Review