Faulty Work Can Be an "Occurrence": What Lee Builders Means for Kansas Contractors
In Kansas, property damage caused by faulty workmanship can be an "occurrence" covered by a contractor's commercial general liability (CGL) policy, as long as the contractor did not intend the damage.
Insurers often tell contractors that a construction defect is not an "accident," so their liability policy does not cover it. In 2006, the Kansas Supreme Court rejected that argument in Lee Builders, Inc. v. Farm Bureau Mutual Insurance Co., 281 Kan. 844 (2006). Jacob S. Graybill argued the case for the contractor, and Russ Hazlewood was on the briefs.
What Happened
Lee Builders, a general contractor, built a custom home in Wichita using subcontractors and turned it over in December 1991. Over the next several years, the homeowner reported leaking windows and cracking, leaking stucco. Moisture got into the walls and caused damage. No one could pinpoint the exact defect.
Lee Builders' CGL insurer denied coverage, saying there was no "occurrence." Lee Builders settled the homeowner's claim together with the window manufacturer, the window retailer and the stucco installer, and then sued its insurer.
What the Court Held
The policy defined "occurrence" as "[a]n accident, including continuous or repeated exposure to substantially the same general harmful conditions," but did not define "accident." Kansas courts define an accident as an undesigned, sudden and unexpected event. The question, the court explained, is whether the damage was intended, not whether the work itself was done on purpose. The Supreme Court quoted the Court of Appeals' rule that coverage "is avoided only when an act results in an intentional injury."
Applying that rule, the court held the damage here was covered. In its words, faulty materials and workmanship provided by the subcontractor "caused continuous exposure of a home" to moisture, "which in turn caused damage that was both unforeseen and unintended."
The court also pointed to the policy itself. The standard CGL form excludes damage to the contractor's own work but makes an exception for work performed by subcontractors. That exception would mean nothing if construction defects could never be occurrences. And because the policy terms were ambiguous, Kansas law required reading them in the insured's favor: "the construction most favorable to the insured must prevail."
Attorney Fees
The Supreme Court upheld an award of attorney fees to the contractor under Kansas's property insurance fee statute and awarded the contractor its attorney fees for the appeal as well. The case went back to the district court only to decide how much of the settlement was caused by the covered damage.
Why It Still Matters
Lee Builders remains a frequently cited Kansas decision on construction defect coverage. For contractors and builders, it means:
1. Don't take "it's not an accident" at face value. Unintended damage caused by faulty work, especially a subcontractor's, can be a covered occurrence.
2. Coverage is about the damage, not the defect. Insurers may still contest the cost of fixing the faulty work itself. The covered loss is the resulting damage, and the court sent the case back to sort out which settlement costs were caused by it.
3. Keep your full policy. The occurrence definition, the "your work" exclusion and its subcontractor exception all mattered. Ask your agent for the complete policy, not just the declarations page.
Liability Claim Denied?
Graybill & Hazlewood represents Kansas contractors and businesses in disputes with their insurers. See our insurance coverage practice and business litigation practice, or call (316) 266-4058.
General information about a public court decision, not legal advice. Every case depends on its own facts and law, and past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Written and reviewed by N. Russell Hazlewood, Kansas attorney since 1998.