Advocating for You in Court and Beyond Team Up With Us
Cover of the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, August 2023 issue

Wait, the Illegal Aliens are Insurance Companies?!? Tools for Identifying and Prosecuting First-Party Claims Against Unauthorized Insurers in Kansas

August 2023 Aug. 1, 2023

By Michelle C. Le and N. Russell Hazlewood

Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, Vol. 47 (August 2023). This article reflects the law as of that date.

When a client presents in your office with a first-party claim against an insurer, one of the first things to consider is whether the insurer is admitted, or at least authorized, to transact insurance business in Kansas. The answer to that inquiry may have a significant impact on your strategy for prosecuting the claim. Let’s consider some of the issues.

What is an admitted insurer?

An “admitted” insurer is an insurance company that has satisfied the requirements of the Kansas Insurance Department (KID) and Chapter 40 of the Kansas statutes and has been granted a certificate of authority from the Commissioner of Insurance to conduct insurance business within the state.

Here are a few key points regarding the significance of whether coverage issued from an admitted insurer:

  1. Consumer Protection: The process of becoming an admitted insurer involves a thorough review of an insurer’s financial stability, business practices, policy forms, rates, and compliance with consumer protection regulations.

  2. Guaranty Fund Coverage: Policyholders of admitted insurers (which the applicable statutes define as “member insurers”) are typically eligible for coverage under the Kansas Insurance Guaranty Association Act.[1] This act provides protection if an insurance company becomes insolvent and is unable to fulfill its obligations. The guaranty fund helps ensure that policyholders are not left without coverage or compensation in such situations.

  3. Compliance and Oversight: Admitted insurers are subject to ongoing oversight and regulation by the KID. They must comply with reporting requirements, solvency standards, consumer protection measures, and other regulatory obligations. The KID reviews and approves both policy forms and premium rates. The KID monitors the financial health and business practices of admitted insurers to safeguard the interests of policyholders.

  4. Market Access: Being an admitted insurer can enhance market access and credibility within the insurance industry. Many agents, brokers, and customers prefer to work with admitted insurers due to the assurance of regulatory oversight and consumer protection.

What are excess & surplus lines?

The market of non-admitted insurers is called the excess & surplus lines market.[2] These companies are not required to adhere to the same Kansas requirements for approval of forms, and rates, etc. This flexibility permits excess and surplus lines insurers to offer coverages for fortuities and losses typically deemed higher-risk, unique, or specialized, and not readily available from admitted insurers. In addition, some E&S insurers have appetites for risk allowing them to provide liability coverages higher than those offered by admitted insurers, as well as coverage for known or unknown gaps that are set forth in a basic policy from a primary insurer (which, itself, may or may not be an admitted insurer).

In Kansas, only those property insurance coverages enumerated in K.S.A. 40-901, casualty insurance coverages enumerated in K.S.A. 40-1102, and reinsurance may be offered by a non-admitted insurer, and then only if such coverages are not readily obtainable in the admitted insurance market.[3]

The forms used by excess and surplus lines insurers are often very different from U.S. insurance industry standard forms (e.g., forms promulgated by Insurance Services Office) or KID-approved forms utilized by admitted insurers. Often, excess and surplus lines policy forms employ language and an organization structure from a foreign insurance market, e.g., the London market. For example, they may have conditions and deductibles not common in the admitted market. Importantly, because they are not subject to the same regulations, excess and surplus lines policies will not be modified by the usual Kansas amendatory endorsements required by KID.

Excess and surplus lines insurers are not free from Kansas regulation, however. K.S.A. 40-246b, et seq., govern the sale of excess and surplus lines insurance to Kansas insureds. To place excess and surplus lines insurance on a Kansas domiciled risk, an insurance agent must hold an excess lines coverage license.[4] Moreover, the Kansas Insurance Commissioner maintains a list of non-admitted insurers authorized to do business in this state; and no excess lines agent may place insurance on a Kansas domiciled risk with an insurer whose name does not appear on that list.[5]

Under what circumstances would someone purchase excess and surplus lines insurance?

Excess and surplus lines policies are intended to be a last resort. They are allowed only for coverages and limits not readily obtainable in the admitted insurance market. Before an excess and surplus lines policy can be issued, the Kansas licensed excess lines agent must conduct a diligent search to determine an inability to procure insurance from an admitted insurer.[6] Further, all excess and surplus lines insurers must provide certain disclosures as well as obtain written consent from the prospective insured regarding the insurer’s non-admitted status.[7] Upon a surplus or foreign/alien excess lines policy being issued in Kansas, it must be stamped or endorsed in a prominent manner with the following admonition: “This policy is issued by an insurer not authorized to do business in Kansas and, as such, the form, financial condition and rates are not subject to review by the commissioner of insurance and the insured is not protected by any guaranty fund.”[8] In addition, the agent who placed the coverage must sign the endorsement, and the stamped endorsement and signature page(s) must be retained in the insured’s file.[9]

How can I determine whether an insurer is admitted or non-admitted?

KID’s website links to a search engine that provides information about the various insurance companies. Currently, the search engine may be found at sbs.naic.org. You may also contact KID by telephone. Also, look for the above-quoted, required endorsement on the policy. Atypical forms are also a frequent indicator.

How can I determine whether a non-admitted insurer is authorized to do insurance business in Kansas?

The search engine above also provides information about excess and surplus lines insurers. In addition, K.S.A. 40-246e requires the Kansas Insurance Commissioner to maintain a list of non-admitted insurers authorized to write excess coverage on Kansas risks. Only those insurers who have filed a certified copy of their most recent annual statement with the Commissioner of Insurance in the form prescribed by K.S.A. 40-225, and amendments thereto, or, if domiciled outside the United States, have filed their most recent annual statement with the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) may appear on the list.[10] You can find the list on KID’s website at insurance.ks.gov. NAIC’s quarterly listing of alien insurers may be found on NAIC’s website at content.naic.org.

How may I serve an admitted or authorized excess & surplus lines insurer?

If the insurer is admitted or authorized to transact business in Kansas, it has appointed the Kansas Commissioner of Insurance as its agent for service of process.[11] KID’s website has a page dedicated to answering frequently asked questions about service of process. When you request your summons, make sure that it provides 40 days to file an answer instead of the standard 21 days.

On the other hand, if the insurer is not admitted or identified on the above-referenced list of authorized companies, it is not allowed to transact business of insurance in this state, and K.S.A. 40-218 does not apply. Instead, Kansas has enacted model rules that apply to unauthorized insurers.

How can an unauthorized insurer be held accountable on a policy of insurance issued on a Kansas risk?

Kansas requires non-admitted insurers to obtain and maintain a certificate of authority from the commissioner of insurance.[12] In order to address those circumstances in which an insurer transacts insurance business without obtaining or maintaining a certificate, Kansas has enacted the “Uniform Unauthorized Insurers Act” (UUIA) and the “Unauthorized Insurers Process Act” (UIPA). Each is a model act promulgated by the NAIC to provide a framework for regulating and overseeing transactions with unauthorized insurers.[13] These acts are intended to protect policyholders and ensure that insurance transactions with unauthorized insurers are conducted fairly and with appropriate consumer protections. They provide for actions in Kansas against, and for the service of process upon, unauthorized insurers; they limit how a defense may be made by these insurers; and they provide for the allowance of attorneys’ fees for prevailing insureds in actions against these insurers.

Uniform Unauthorized Insurers Act

The Kansas UUIA has been codified at K.S.A. 40-2701 et seq. Its purpose is to protect Kansas residents against unauthorized insurers by maintaining fair and honest insurance markets, protecting authorized insurers which are subject to regulation from unfair competition by unauthorized insurers and by protecting against the evasion of the insurance regulatory laws of this state.[14] The UUIA declares it unlawful for any insurer to transact insurance business in Kansas without a certificate of authority from the Commissioner of Insurance.

Under the UUIA, if the Commissioner of Insurance believes that an insurer is violating or about to violate the requirements to maintain a certificate of authority from the KID, it may, through the Kansas Attorney General, cause a complaint to be filed in a district court of proper venue to enjoin or restrain such insurer from continuing such violation.[15] The district court has full authority and power to make and enter any order or judgment awarding a preliminary or final injunction within its discretion that is proper.[16] An insurer convicted of transacting any unauthorized act of insurance business may also be fined not more than $10,000.[17]

Unauthorized Insurers Process Act

The UIPA, codified at K.S.A. 40-2001 et seq., may be more helpful in civil claims by consumers who are forced to hire an attorney to recover benefits from an unauthorized insurer. The UIPA’s stated purpose is to protect the residents of Kansas against resorting to being the subject of jurisdiction in a distant forum, thereby providing a method of substitute service of process on such unauthorized insurers.[18] The UIPA appoints the Commissioner of Insurance as the true and lawful attorney for service on an unauthorized insurer of any action, suit or proceeding instituted by or on behalf of an insured or beneficiary arising out of any such contract of insurance.[19] Once service of process is made upon the Commissioner of Insurance, KID will forward the served papers onto the unauthorized insurer at its last known principal place of business.[20]

Once served, before any foreign or alien unauthorized insurer can file a pleading, the insurer must post a bond sufficient to secure payment of a final judgment that may be rendered in such action.[21] If, for example, the prayer for damages in your petition or complaint is $1,000,000, the insurer must post a bond for that amount before it can file a responsive pleading.

In our experience, some unauthorized insurers will attempt to bond through a similarly unreliable foreign or alien surety. That will not satisfy its obligation, and you should object. For example, U.S. D. Kan. Rule 65.2 provides, inter alia:

Unless the court directs otherwise, every bond or undertaking must be secured by:

(1) a cash deposit equal to the amount of the bond;

(2) a corporation authorized to execute bonds under 31 U.S.C. §§ 9304–9308;[22] or

(3) an individual residing in the District of Kansas owning sufficient unencumbered real or personal property within the district above all homestead and exemption rights and all obligations as surety, to insure the payment of the amount of the bond and all costs incident to collecting the same. (Emphasis added).

The UUIA also provides for a mandatory award of attorney’s fees in favor of a prevailing insured or beneficiary, to be taxed as a part of the costs of the action, in all cases where judgment is rendered against an unauthorized, foreign, or alien insurer that fails or refuses to pay the full amount of an insured loss, provided that the judgment exceeds the insurer’s pre-suit tender.[23] Although there are other fee-shifting statutes that might also apply to a given claim against an unauthorized insurer, this provision of the UUIA will be the broadest available, because K.S.A. 40-908 is limited in application by the scope of risks insured by the policy, and K.S.A. 40-256 requires a showing that the insurer failed to pay the full amount of the loss without just cause or excuse.

In summary, on the rare occasion you encounter a claim against an unauthorized insurer in Kansas, the law will permit you to serve the carrier with your lawsuit through the Commissioner of Insurance; to have the court require a bond for the full amount of your claim before the carrier can file an answer or other responsive pleading to your petition or complaint; and to collect your attorney’s fees for prosecuting the action if you recover a judgment in excess of the insurer’s pre-suit tender. In our experience, these tools are both useful and effective in getting these claims resolved quickly. Good hunting.

Endnotes

  1. See K.S.A. 40-2901 et seq.

  2. Some excess lines insurers are admitted insurers in Kansas.

  3. K.S.A. 40-246b – 40-246c.

  4. K.S.A. 40-246b.

  5. K.S.A. 40-246e.

  6. K.S.A. 40-246b(b).

  7. Id.; see also the form statement available on KID’s website. There is an exemption from this requirement for insureds who are “Exempt Commercial Purchasers” defined in K.S.A. 40-246i[a].

  8. K.S.A. 40-246b(d) (emphasis added).

  9. K.A.R. 40-8-11.

  10. K.S.A. 40-246e.

  11. K.S.A. 40-218.

  12. K.S.A. 40-2702(a).

  13. Kansas has also adopted other model laws from the NAIC including regulating unauthorized insurers from false or misleading advertising known as the Unauthorized Insurers False Advertising Process Act. K.S.A. 40-2415, et seq. For further information on these model laws, see NAIC’s model laws page.

  14. K.S.A. 40-2701.

  15. K.S.A. 40-2703.

  16. K.S.A. 40-2703.

  17. K.S.A. 40-2707.

  18. K.S.A. 40-2001.

  19. K.S.A. 40-2002(a).

  20. K.S.A. 40-2002(b).

  21. K.S.A. 40-2003.

  22. 31 U.S.C. § 9305 authorizes the U.S. Secretary of Treasury to authorize a surety company to provide surety bonds under § 9304.

  23. K.S.A. 40-2004 (emphasis added). See also Nicklin v. Harper, 18 Kan. App. 2d 760, 771, 860 P.2d 31, 39 (1993) (in reversing attorney’s fees awarded under the UIPA, the court held the UIPA only applies to unauthorized insurers and not authorized foreign or alien insurers).