Advocating for You in Court and Beyond Team Up With Us
Cover of the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, May 2022 issue

Multi-State Endorsements: Ambiguous Language and the Kansas Rule of Lex Loci Contractus

May 2022 May 1, 2022

By Michelle C. Le

Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, Vol. 45 (May 2022). This article reflects the law as of that date.

Can you expand an insured’s rights under an insurance policy when it appears these rights are limited by a state specific endorsement? Under the right circumstances, you can.

Commercial property insurers are required to submit basic policies to state regulators in order to get approval to use them in that particular state. Once approved, insurers can include endorsements to the policy, which is a form that becomes part of the insurance policy, altering the policy’s coverage. A commercial property insurance endorsement can add, remove, modify, limit, exclude, or qualify certain coverages. Common changes might include, for example, imposing state-specific requirements for appraisal of loss, imposing state-specific limitations on the time to file a lawsuit, or imposing state-specific changes to the loss settlement provisions.

Commercial property insurers routinely sell single policy packages to business owners who own property in multiple states while including state specific endorsements. These endorsements allow changes to be made to the basic policies without requiring the insured to take out a different policy for each such property. However, because these endorsements make changes to basic policies approved by the regulators of a particular state, they open the potential for conflicting policy language.

Identifying Ambiguities in Insurance Contracts

The rules of insurance policy contract interpretation are well-established in Kansas. “An insurance policy is ambiguous when it contains language of doubtful or conflicting meaning based on a reasonable construction of the policy’s language.”[1] However, a disagreement by the parties on the interpretation of the language does not create an ambiguity. Id. If no ambiguity exists, the policy “must be construed in its plain, ordinary and popular sense and according to the sense and meaning of the terms used.” Id. Further, when reading an endorsement in a policy, “[t]he policy remains in full force and effect except as altered by the words of the endorsement.”[2] To identify ambiguities in policies, Kansas courts will not consider what the insurer intended the language to mean.[3] Instead, they “must view the language as to what a reasonably prudent insured would understand the language to mean.” Id. Further, it is the duty of the insurer as the drafter to use clear and unambiguous language and use clear and explicit terms when defining limitations in order to effectively limit coverage. Id. If it does not, “the insurance policy will be construed in favor of the insured.” Id.

If you find yourself in a situation where an insurer who has sold one of these multi-location risk policies is attempting to limit your client’s coverage, for example, by enforcing a particular state’s endorsement, analyze the endorsements carefully in conjunction with the policy. Determine if there is more than one reasonable interpretation or any conflicting language between the endorsements, thus creating an ambiguity. Then, determine whether or not you can expand coverage for your client by applying the interpretation that most favors the insured.

Practical Example

Sec. Storage Properties, et al. v. Safeco Ins. Co. of Am., No. 09-1036-WEB-DWB, 2010 WL 1936127 (D. Kan. May 12, 2010)

My firm had a situation where our clients purchased a multi-location commercial insurance policy. Our clients, whose principal places of business were located in Kansas, owned storage units in multiple states, including Texas and Kansas. The policy was issued and delivered to our clients in Kansas. The policy included a state-specific endorsement for each state where insured units were located. However, the policy did not explain which endorsements applied to which properties. A hurricane caused damages to our clients’ storage units located in Houston, Texas. After our clients provided notice of loss to their insurer, the insurer partially paid the claim for the loss and delivered the payment to our clients in Kansas. Our clients disagreed with the assessment of the loss and underpayment of the claim. In an attempt to resolve the disputed damages, the insurer invoked the appraisal provision within the policy and specifically sought to enforce the Texas endorsement. Under the Texas endorsement, either the policyholder or the insurer could unilaterally force the other party into an appraisal, which would limit the damages to an amount agreed upon by third parties during the process.

Because the insurance policy was issued and delivered in Kansas, to Kansas domiciled insureds, and because the Kansas and Texas endorsements had conflicting language, ambiguity was manifest. Under the Kansas endorsement, neither party could unilaterally compel appraisal, making the provision voluntary rather than mandatory. Therefore, the Kansas endorsement was most favorable to our clients. We came to this conclusion based upon a careful reading of the declarations revealing they were unclear as to which endorsements applied to which location. In addition, we argued there was no concise and clear language in the policy which stated that the Texas endorsement applied to the Texas property. The insurer refused to interpret the policy as demanded, and we filed a declaratory action seeking a declaratory judgment concerning the parties’ rights under the policy.

A determination of which endorsement applied hinged on whether the policy required our clients to submit their loss through the binding appraisal process as required by the Texas endorsement or whether the policy allowed for our clients to forego appraisal as allowed by the Kansas endorsement. The endorsement for Texas read as follows:

THIS ENDORSEMENT CHANGES THE POLICY. PLEASE READ IT CAREFULLY.

TEXAS AMENDATORY ENDORSEMENT

…

CONDITIONS

…

B. CONDITIONS APPLICABLE TO PART ONE

2. Appraisal is replaced by the following:

2. Appraisal

If we and you disagree on the amount of “loss,” either may make written demand for an appraisal of the “loss.” In this event, each party will select a competent and impartial appraiser within 20 days of the receipt of the written demand. The two appraisers will select an umpire. If they cannot agree within 15 days either may request that selection be made by a judge of a court having jurisdiction. The appraisers will state separately the amount of the “loss.” If they fail to agree, they will submit their differences to the umpire. A decision agreed to by any two of the appraisers and the umpire will be binding. Each party will:

a. Pay its chosen appraiser; and

b. Bear the other expenses of the appraisal and umpire equally.

The Kansas endorsement read as follows:

THIS ENDORSEMENT CHANGES THE POLICY. PLEASE READ IT CAREFULLY.

AMENDATORY ENDORSEMENT KANSAS CHANGES

…

CONDITIONS

…

B. Conditions Applicable to Part One

Condition 2. is replaced by the following:

2. Appraisal

If you and we disagree on the amount of the loss, either may make written demand for an appraisal of the loss. However, an appraisal will be made only if both of you and we agree, voluntarily, to have the loss appraised. In this event, each party will select a competent and impartial appraiser. The two appraisers will select an umpire. If they cannot agree, either may request that selection be made by a judge of a court having jurisdiction. The appraisers will state separately the amount of the loss. If they fail to agree, they will submit their differences to the umpire. A decision agreed to by any two will be binding. Each party will:

a. Pay its chosen appraiser; and

b. Bear the other expenses of the appraisal and umpire equally.

If there is an appraisal, we will still retain our right to deny the claim.

In its initial arguments, the insurer conceded to the federal court that Kansas law applied to the interpretation of the policy. The insurer argued, however, that the only reasonable conclusion was that each state-specific endorsement intended to modify the terms of the policy for the properties located in that state as listed on the declarations page. In support, it argued that there were nine different state-specific endorsements that corresponded only to the states where the properties were located.

In contrast, we argued that because each endorsement purports to amend the same provisions of the policy (one endorsement making appraisal mandatory and the other voluntary), the provisions are ambiguous or uncertain, conflicting, or susceptible of more than one construction such that the provision favorable to the insureds must prevail, i.e., the Kansas endorsement applied.

The Kansas rule of lex loci contractus

The parties also disagreed as to which state’s law applied. In order to determine choice of law in a contract, there are two general rules that apply in Kansas: (1) the law of the place where the contract was entered, and (2) the law of the place of performance.[4] When the question raised goes to the substance of the obligation, the Kansas rule of lex loci contractus states that a contract shall be interpreted by the law of the place where the contract was made.[5] On the other hand, if the question is the manner and method of performance, then the law of the place of performance applies.[6]

The insurer argued that Kansas would not apply the rule of lex loci contractus in this situation because it would look to the law in the place of performance. Further, that place of performance would be Texas because the duty to pay for the loss arose in Texas to our clients’ Texas properties which required the insurer to adjust the loss in Texas. However, the insurer also conceded that the policy did not contain an express choice of law provision, but it argued that the intention of the policy was to apply the state specific laws as stated in the endorsements to the properties in each of those states.

We argued that the place where the contract was entered was Kansas, and therefore the Kansas rule of lex loci contractus requires Kansas law to apply. But in any event, the place of performance was also Kansas which required the insurer to deliver payments to the named insureds at their principal place of business in Kansas.

In applying the choice of law rules, the court concluded that the question presented went to the substance and effect of the insurance contract, and not merely to a detail regarding the manner of performance. In so concluding, the court invoked the Kansas rule of lex loci contractus and applied Kansas laws to the interpretation of the Kansas and Texas endorsements. In applying Kansas rules of interpretation in insurance policies:

[t]he language of an insurance policy, like any other contract, must, if possible, be construed in such way as to give effect to the intention of the parties. In construing a policy of insurance, a court should consider the instrument as a whole and endeavor to ascertain the intention of the parties from the language used, taking into account the situation of the parties, the nature of the subject matter, and the purpose to be accomplished.

Because the insurer prepares its contracts, it has a duty to make the meaning clear. If the insurer intends to restrict or limit coverage under the policy, it must use clear and unambiguous language; otherwise, the policy will be liberally construed in favor of the insureds. If an insurance policy’s language is clear and unambiguous, it must be taken in its plain, ordinary, and popular sense. In such case, there is no need for judicial interpretation or the application of rules of liberal construction. The court shall not make another contract for the parties and must enforce the contract as made.

However, where the terms of an insurance policy are ambiguous or uncertain, conflicting, or susceptible of more than one construction, the construction most favorable to the insureds must prevail.[7]

After a careful review of the policy language and each state-specific endorsement, the court held that because the Kansas and Texas endorsements contained contradictory appraisal provisions, both could not apply to a given claim. In addition, because there was no express provision as to when or how a state specific endorsement should apply, the contract was susceptible to more than one reasonable interpretation. That is, it could be understood as the insurer argued, the intent was for the state specific endorsement to apply to the property located in that particular state. On the other hand, as we argued, a reasonable insured could understand the endorsement that applies is dependent upon where the contract was entered or the residence of the insured, with the Kansas endorsement applicable to a policy made and delivered to an insured in Kansas, and the Texas endorsement to apply to a policy made and delivered to an insured in Texas, in order to ensure the policy complies with the laws of the forum state.[8]

The court held because the policy language was ambiguous in this respect, it must apply the application most favorable to the insureds. We made a convincing argument to the court, and therefore, we effectively stopped the insurer from enforcing Texas’s one-sided appraisal provision, by requiring it to apply the Kansas endorsement. In addition, the uncontroverted facts showed that our clients had not elected to submit the loss to appraisal. Therefore, the court held that our clients could not be forced to participate in the appraisal process pursuant to the Kansas endorsement, because they had not agreed to do so.

Although we were successful in our case, other jurisdictions have analyzed multi-state endorsements, mostly in the context of COVID-19 coverage cases. In this context, some courts have concluded that the state-specific endorsements at issue applied only to those businesses located in that particular state and declined to expand coverage. See, e.g., AECOM v. Zurich Am. Ins. Co., No. LACV2100237JAKMRWX, 2021 WL 6425546, at 10 (C.D. Cal. Dec. 1, 2021); Lindenwood Female Coll. v. Zurich Am. Ins. Co., No. 4:20CV1503 HEA, 2021 WL 5050065, at 6 (E.D. Mo. Nov. 1, 2021); Manhattan Partners, LLC v. Am. Guarantee & Liab. Ins. Co., No. 20-14342 (SDW) (LDW), 2021 WL 1016113, at 2 n.3 (D.N.J. Mar. 17, 2021); Firebirds Int’l, LLC v. Zurich Am. Ins. Co., No. 2020-CH-05360, slip op. at 10 (Ill. Cir. Ct. Cook Cty. Apr. 19, 2021); Valley Health Sys. Inc. v. Zurich Am. Ins. Co., No. BER-L-1907-21, 2021 WL 4958349, at 10 (N.J. Super. Ct. Oct. 18, 2021); Am. Internat. Specialty Lines Ins. Co. v. Cont’l Cas. Ins. Co., 142 Cal. App. 4th 1342, 1362 (2006).

As you can see, these multi-location risk policies are susceptible to ambiguities. Therefore, contract language interpretation is key to establish all rights of an insured where it appears the insured’s rights may be limited by one state’s endorsement. Unless there is clear and concise language limiting the rights of the insured to that particular state’s endorsement, courts will enforce a reasonable interpretation in favor of the insured expanding those rights. If you are able to make a convincing argument creating an ambiguity between different state’s endorsements, it could help establish or expand coverage for your client where it appears it is limited or excluded in its entirety.

Endnotes

  1. Karlin v. Paul Revere Life Ins. Co., 742 F. Supp. 2d 1253, 1262 (D. Kan. 2010).

  2. 4 Holmes’ Appleman on Insurance 2d § 20.1, p. 153 (1998).

  3. Karlin, 742 F. Supp. 2d at 1262.

  4. Moses v. Halstead, 581 F.3d 1248, 1252 (10th Cir. 2009) (citations omitted).

  5. Simms v. Metropolitan Life Ins. Co., 685 P.2d 321, 324 (Kan. App. 1984).

  6. Moses, 581 F.3d at 1252.

  7. American Family Mut. Ins. Co. v. Wilkins, 285 Kan. 1054, 1058–59, 179 P.3d 1104 (2008) (citations omitted).

  8. Cf. Travelers Cas. & Surety Co. v. Honeywell Intern., Inc., 63 A.D.3d 451, 880 N.Y.S.2d 66 (2009); Humbert v. United Ohio Ins. Co., 154 Ohio App. 3d 540, 798 N.E.2d 25 (2003) (“the mere presence of state-specific endorsements in an insurance policy is not an affirmative choice of the law of any particular state” under Restatement (Second) of Conflicts of Law).