Mandatory Vaccination – Myth or Reality?
By Sean M. McGivern
Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, Vol. 45 (November 2021). This article reflects the law as of that date; the law governing COVID-19 vaccination requirements has changed substantially since publication.
COVID-19 continues to play a major role in our lives. A year ago, the issues were masks, social distancing, and voluntary vaccinations. Now the issue is mandatory vaccination in the workplace. This article provides a snapshot of the law regarding mandatory vaccinations in Kansas and in the workplace.
1. Does the federal constitution prohibit the government from imposing a policy of mandatory vaccination during a public health crisis?
Under prevailing law, the answer is “generally, no.” See Jacobson v. Massachusetts, 197 U.S. 11, 31 (1905) (compulsory vaccination is constitutional), cited in Dunn v. White, 880 F.2d 1188, 1195 (10th Cir. 1989) (mandatory AIDS test of inmates is constitutional). Many groups are proposing to challenge Jacobson, but it remains good law. Though Jacobson permits the government to restrict or mandate people’s activities, it does not permit the government to restrict religious activities more than secular activities. Roman Cath. Diocese of Brooklyn v. Cuomo, 141 S. Ct. 63, 69 (2020) (Gorsuch, J., concurring).
2. Does Kansas have specific laws on mandatory vaccinations?
In Rhodenbaugh v. Kansas Emp. Sec. Bd. of Rev., 52 Kan. App. 2d 621 (2016), the Court of Appeals considered an unemployment appeal by a school employee who was fired for refusing to get a flu shot. The employer’s mandatory vaccination policy did allow for medical and religious exemptions. The employee provided a letter to the employer with anecdotal reasons why she was refusing the vaccine, however, she was terminated for failing to comply with the mandate.
On appeal, the court affirmed the Kansas Department of Labor’s finding that the employee had engaged in statutory misconduct sufficient to disqualify her from receiving unemployment benefits. Specifically, “The [mandatory vaccination] rule is … lawful because there is nothing in Kansas or Federal law that prevents the Hospital from requiring vaccinations. It is a legal policy to implement, and provides for exceptions that are nearly identical to Kansas’ exceptions to vaccinations for schoolchildren. See K.S.A. 72–5209(b) [now K.S.A. 72-6262(b)].”
Kansas has specific laws that address the vaccination of children at childcare facilities (K.S.A. 65-508) and in schools (K.S.A. 72-6262). These laws both provide exemptions to individuals who provide: (1) certification from a licensed physician stating that the physical condition of the child is such that immunization would endanger the child’s life or health; or (2) a written statement signed by a parent or guardian that the parent or guardian is an adherent of a religious denomination whose teachings are opposed to immunizations. Notably, K.S.A. 72-6265 states that school boards may exclude individuals who fail to present certifications required by statute.
On May 21, 2021, SB 159 was signed into law by Gov. Kelly. Section 59 of that law provides:
(a) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, no state agency … shall expend any [funds allocated or received in 2021] to: (1) Issue a COVID-19 vaccination passport to any individual without such individual’s consent; (2) require an individual to use a COVID-19 vaccination passport within this state for any purpose; or (3) deny housing or refuse access to a place accessible to the general public, or separate from others in a place accessible to the general public, including entry, education, travel and services within this state, based on such individual’s COVID-19 vaccination status: Provided, however, That nothing in this section shall prohibit a state agency from instituting COVID-19 screening protocols in accordance with state and federal law to protect the public health.
3. Do employment laws provide grounds for employees to refuse COVID-19 vaccination?
Employees have two potential avenues to avoid mandatory workplace vaccination policies under law: request an accommodation under (i) disability-discrimination laws (i.e., the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Rehabilitation Act of 1973), and (ii) religion-discrimination laws (i.e., Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964). All employees, state and local, with 15 or more employees are covered under the ADA and Title VII. However, federal employees must comply with the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 instead of the ADA.
4. Under the ADA, Title VII, and other employment nondiscrimination laws, may an employer require all employees to be vaccinated?
The federal Equal Employment Opportunity laws do not prevent an employer from requiring all employees physically entering the workplace to be vaccinated for COVID-19, subject to the reasonable accommodation provisions of Title VII and the ADA and other EEO considerations discussed below. These principles apply if an employee gets the vaccine in the community or from the employer.
In some circumstances, Title VII and the ADA require an employer to provide reasonable accommodations for employees who, because of a disability or a sincerely held religious belief, practice, or observance, do not get vaccinated for COVID-19, unless providing an accommodation would pose an undue hardship on the operation of the employer’s business. The analysis for undue hardship depends on whether the accommodation is for a disability (including pregnancy-related conditions that constitute a disability) or for religion.
A request for exemption due to personal or philosophical reasons is not protected by law and the employer should reiterate the company policy and the consequences for non-compliance with a vaccine mandate.
5. Under the ADA, if an employer requires COVID-19 vaccinations for employees physically entering the workplace, how should an employee who does not get a COVID-19 vaccination because of a disability inform the employer, and what should the employer do?
An employee with a disability who does not get vaccinated for COVID-19 because of a disability must let the employer know that he or she needs an exemption from the requirement or a change at work, known as a reasonable accommodation. To request an accommodation, an individual does not need to mention the ADA or use the phrase “reasonable accommodation.”
Managers and supervisors responsible for communicating with employees about compliance with the employer’s vaccination requirement should know how to recognize an accommodation request from an employee with a disability and know to whom to refer the request for full consideration. As a best practice, before instituting a mandatory vaccination policy, employers should provide managers, supervisors, and those responsible for implementing the policy with clear information about how to handle accommodation requests related to the policy.
Employers and employees typically engage in a flexible, interactive process to identify workplace accommodation options that do not impose an undue hardship (significant difficulty or expense) on the employer. This process may include determining whether it is necessary to obtain supporting medical documentation about the employee’s disability.
In discussing accommodation requests, employers and employees may find it helpful to consult the Job Accommodation Network (JAN) website as a resource for different types of accommodations. JAN’s materials about COVID-19 are available at askjan.org.
Employers also may consult applicable Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) COVID-specific resources. Even if there is no reasonable accommodation that will allow the unvaccinated employee to be physically present to perform his or her current job without posing a direct threat, the employer must consider if telework is an option for that particular job as an accommodation and, as a last resort, whether reassignment to another position is possible.
The ADA requires that employers offer an available accommodation if one exists that does not pose an undue hardship, meaning a significant difficulty or expense. See 29 C.F.R. 1630.2(p). Employers are advised to consider all the options before denying an accommodation request. The proportion of employees in the workplace who already are partially or fully vaccinated against COVID-19 and the extent of employee contact with non-employees, who may be ineligible for a vaccination or whose vaccination status may be unknown, can impact the ADA undue hardship consideration. Employers may rely on CDC recommendations when deciding whether an effective accommodation is available that would not pose an undue hardship.
Under the ADA, it is unlawful for an employer to disclose that an employee is receiving a reasonable accommodation or to retaliate against an employee for requesting an accommodation.
6. Under Title VII, how should an employer respond to an employee who communicates that he or she is unable to be vaccinated for COVID-19 (or provide documentation or other confirmation of vaccination) because of a sincerely held religious belief, practice, or observance?
Under federal law, sincerely held religious beliefs include moral or ethical beliefs as to what is right and wrong which are sincerely held with the strength of traditional religious views. Moreover, the term “religion” includes all aspects of religious observance and practice, as well as belief. But this doesn’t mean that an employee can get a free pass just because they personally or philosophically do not agree with receiving the vaccine.
In order to assess whether the requested exception is a sincerely held religious belief, the employer should require the employee clearly state the nature of the religious belief, practice or observance. If necessary, appropriate documentation from his or her religious or faith-based leader regarding the claimed belief and how it conflicts with the belief should be considered and documented. Helpful hints can be found in the EEOC’s questions and answers on religious discrimination in the workplace.
Once an employer is on notice that an employee’s sincerely held religious belief, practice, or observance prevents the employee from getting a COVID-19 vaccine, the employer must provide a reasonable accommodation unless it would pose an undue hardship. Employers also may receive religious accommodation requests from individuals who wish to wait until an alternative version or specific brand of COVID-19 vaccine is available to the employee. Such requests should be processed according to the same standards that apply to other accommodation requests.
EEOC guidance explains that the definition of religion is broad and protects beliefs, practices, and observances with which the employer may be unfamiliar. Therefore, the employer should ordinarily assume that an employee’s request for religious accommodation is based on a sincerely held religious belief, practice, or observance. However, if an employee requests a religious accommodation, and an employer is aware of facts that provide an objective basis for questioning either the religious nature or the sincerity of a particular belief, practice, or observance, the employer would be justified in requesting additional supporting information. See also 29 C.F.R. 1605.
Under Title VII, an employer should thoroughly consider all possible reasonable accommodations, including telework and reassignment. For suggestions about types of reasonable accommodation for unvaccinated employees, see above. In many circumstances, it may be possible to accommodate those seeking reasonable accommodations for their religious beliefs, practices, or observances.
Under Title VII, courts define “undue hardship” as having more than minimal cost or burden on the employer. This is an easier standard for employers to meet than the ADA’s undue hardship standard, which applies to requests for accommodations due to a disability. Considerations relevant to undue hardship can include, among other things, the proportion of employees in the workplace who already are partially or fully vaccinated against COVID-19 and the extent of employee contact with non-employees, whose vaccination status could be unknown or who may be ineligible for the vaccine. Ultimately, if an employee cannot be accommodated, employers should determine if any other rights apply under the EEO laws or other federal, state, and local authorities before taking adverse employment action against an unvaccinated employee.
Caveats
Caution must be exercised in how policies and protocols are implemented for vaccine policies involving COVID-19; how employee requests for exemption are handled; and how applications and interviews for new hires are processed. There are pitfalls and the best approach is to know the laws and document every step of each of these processes. This article provides only an overview of the laws. An excellent resource to further assist practitioners is the EEOC’s “What You Should Know About COVID-19 and the ADA, the Rehabilitation Act, and Other EEO Laws.”