Advocating for You in Court and Beyond Team Up With Us

Liability Insurance for Intentional Torts: An Introduction to Coverage for Personal and Advertising Injury

July 2013 July 1, 2013

By N. Russell Hazlewood

Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Association for Justice, Vol. 36 (July 2013). This article reflects the law as of that date.

We are all familiar with the term “personal injury.” In common parlance, the term describes an injury to one’s mind or body. However, in the world of liability insurance, that type of injury is known as “bodily injury.” “Personal injury” is something altogether different — it refers to a category of injury for which available liability insurance coverage is frequently overlooked.

Liability insurers and their counsel often attempt to justify the denial of a liability claim by invoking the well-known, but also non-existent “intentional act exclusion.” In some instances, counsel for the claimant, personal counsel for the liability insured, and even courts get caught up in this misnomer, because they fail to understand that the insurance policy at issue does not exclude coverage for intentional acts.[1]

Sometimes, these common misunderstandings result in circumstances where a claimant does not recover or where a liability insured is not afforded a defense or indemnity for a covered claim. This article is intended to help the reader recognize and exploit coverage for personal and advertising injury.

Most lawyers are familiar with Coverage A in a standard form commercial general liability insurance policy (or CGL). The Coverage A insuring agreement obligates the insurer to pay the insured’s legal liability to pay damages because of bodily injury or property damage caused by an “occurrence” (or accident) to which the insurance applies.[2] The insurer has both the right and duty to defend the insured from a suit seeking those damages. Coverage A defines “bodily injury” the way most people think of personal injury, i.e., “bodily injury, sickness or disease sustained by a person, including death resulting from any of these at any time.”[3]

Fewer lawyers are knowledgeable about Coverage B, although it is standard in commercial general liability policies. Generally speaking, Coverage B encompasses intellectual property claims and other various torts, and categories of damages that fall outside of Coverage A. With regard to certain offenses, coverage is afforded even where there is no bodily injury or property damage, and even where the conduct complained of was intentional.

Coverage B contains a stand-alone insuring agreement covering the insured’s legal obligation to pay damages for personal and advertising injury, to which the insurance applies.[4] To be sure, Coverage B does not insure all risks excluded by Coverage A. Coverage is limited to personal and advertising injury, which the policy defines as injury arising out of the invasion of another’s rights by one or more of seven enumerated “offenses:”[5]

a) False arrest, detention or imprisonment;

b) Malicious prosecution;

c) The wrongful eviction from, wrongful entry into, or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a room, dwelling or premises that a person occupies, committed by or on behalf of its owner, landlord or lessor;

d) Oral or written publication, in any manner, of material that slanders or libels a person or organization or disparages a person’s or organization’s goods, products or services;

e) Oral or written publication, in any manner, of material that violates a person’s right of privacy;

f) The use of another’s advertising idea in [the insured’s] “advertisement;”[6] or

g) Infringing upon another’s copyright, trade dress or slogan in [the insured’s] “advertisement.”

As with Coverage A, the insurer has both the right and duty to defend its insured from a suit seeking damages for personal and advertising injury. Unlike Coverage A, coverage for personal and advertising injury is not triggered by accidental occurrences. (The terms, “occurrence” and “accident,” are nowhere to be found in Coverage B).

Notably, coverage under this part may include protection for injuries caused by one or more intentional acts. In fact, most of the offenses covered by Coverage B are, by nature, intentional torts. Nevertheless, as discussed below, the insured’s subjective intentions are not irrelevant. For example, coverage may be excluded for a knowing invasion of another’s rights, criminal activity, and promotional material that is intentionally misleading.

Coverages A and B also contain stand-alone exclusionary provisions. Stated another way, Coverage A exclusions are irrelevant to claims made under Coverage B and vice versa. Loosely paraphrased, the 16 exclusions applicable only to claims made under Coverage B are:

a) Knowing violation of the rights of another: expected personal and advertising injury caused by a knowing violation of the rights of another;

b) Material published with knowledge of its falsity: personal and advertising injury arising out of an oral or written publication made at the direction of the insured with knowledge of its falsity;

c) Material published prior to the policy period: personal and advertising injury arising out of material whose first publication took place prior to the policy period;

d) Criminal acts: personal and advertising injury arising out of a criminal act committed by or at the direction of the insured;

e) Contractual liability: personal and advertising injury for which the insured has assumed liability in a contract or agreement, except where the insured would have such liability in the absence of the contract or agreement;

f) Breach of contract: personal and advertising injury arising out of a breach of contract, except an implied contract to use another’s advertising idea in the insured’s advertisement;

g) Failure of the insured’s goods to conform to statements concerning quality or performance: personal and advertising injury arising out of the failure of goods, products or services to conform with any statement of quality or performance made in the insured’s advertisement;

h) Wrong description of prices: personal and advertising injury arising out of the wrong description of the price of goods, products or services stated in the insured’s advertisement;

i) Infringement of copyright, patent, trademark or trade secret: personal and advertising injury arising out of the infringement of copyright, patent, trademark, trade secret or other intellectual property rights (except for the use of another’s advertising idea in the insured’s advertisement);

j) Insureds in media and Internet type businesses: personal and advertising injury committed by an insured whose business is: (1) advertising, broadcasting, publishing or telecasting; (2) designing or determining content of web sites for others; or (3) an Internet search, access, content or service provider, except for the offenses of false arrest, detention or imprisonment; malicious prosecution; and wrongful eviction, wrongful entry or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a room, dwelling or premises;

k) Electronic chatrooms or bulletin boards: personal and advertising injury arising out of an electronic chatroom or bulletin board the insured hosts, owns, or controls;

l) Unauthorized use of another’s name or product: personal and advertising injury arising out of the unauthorized use of another’s name or product in the insured’s email address, domain name or metatag, or other similar tactics to mislead potential customers;

m) Pollution: personal and advertising injury arising out of the actual, alleged or threatened discharge, dispersal, seepage, migration, release or escape of “pollutants” at any time;

n) Pollution-related: any loss, cost or expense arising out of any: (1) request, demand, order or statutory or regulatory requirement that any insured or others test for, monitor, clean up, remove, contain, treat, detoxify or neutralize, or in any way respond to, or assess the effects of, pollutants; or (2) claim or suit by or on behalf of a governmental authority for damages because of such activities;

o) War: personal and advertising injury arising out of war, rebellion, insurrection or the like; and

p) Recording and distribution of material or information in violation of law: personal and advertising injury arising out of any action or omission that violates or is alleged to violate: (1) The Telephone Consumer Protection Act; (2) The CAN-SPAM Act of 2003; (3) The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) / Fair and Accurate Credit Transactions Act (FACTA); or any law that addresses, prohibits, or limits the printing, dissemination, disposal, collecting, recording, sending, transmitting, communicating or distribution of material or information.[7]

Although the insuring agreements and exclusions of Coverages A and B are separate and distinct, some other provisions of the policy apply to both. These include Section II – Who is an Insured; Section III – Limits of Insurance (there is a separate limit for personal and advertising injury, subject to the general aggregate limit); and Section IV – Commercial General Liability Conditions.

Coverage for personal and advertising injury is not limited to commercial liability insurance forms. Some homeowners and renters liability policies also provide coverage for injuries arising from the enumerated offenses, with similar provisions.

Finally, it is important to note that, while personal and advertising injury caused by familiar torts, such as malicious prosecution and defamation, are obviously covered, the word “offense” does not limit personal and advertising injury coverage to any particular cause of action or claim.

Here are a few illustrative cases demonstrating the potential breadth and usefulness of the coverage:

Coverage for Intentional Interference with Contract/Business Relations

In Bankwest v. Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Maryland, 63 F.3d 974 (10th Cir. 1995), the plaintiff in the underlying action sued his bank for tortious interference with business relations, claiming it told other banks they were estopped from advancing him money.

The Tenth Circuit, interpreting Kansas law, held that the bank’s liability insurer was obligated to defend it, under the policy’s personal injury coverage, because the alleged interference was based on the publication of false statements. See also, United Wats, Inc. v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., 971 F. Supp. 1375 (D. Kan. 1997) (Long-distance telephone provider’s tortious interference claim alleging that competitor made false statements about provider in its attempts to solicit customers was covered under personal injury provision of CGL).

The Missouri Supreme Court reached a similar conclusion in McCormack Baron Mgmt. Servs., Inc. v. Am. Guarantee & Liab. Ins. Co., 989 S.W.2d 168 (Mo. 1999). In the underlying case, a security guard employed by a contractor sued a real estate management company for tortious interference with contract, claiming that he was fired because an apartment manager accused him of “insubordination” and asked that he be removed from his post.

The Missouri Supreme Court held that the management company’s insurer was obligated to defend the claim, under the personal injury coverage, because the alleged interference involved disparaging remarks.

Coverage for Tenant’s Wrongful Abandonment of Property on Leasehold

In FLM, LLC v. Cincinnati Ins. Co., 973 N.E.2d 1167 (Ind. Ct. App. 2012), the Indiana Court of Appeals held that a lessor’s claim against an industrial tenant for abandoning more than 100,000 tons of sand on the leasehold property and subjecting the landlord to environmental liabilities was potentially subject to personal injury coverage for wrongful entry or invasion of the right of private occupancy of a premises.

Coverage for Trespass and Nuisance

In Hartford Fire Ins. Co. v. Gandy Dancer, LLC, 864 F. Supp. 2d 1157 (D. N.M. 2012), the court held that a commercial general liability insurer’s duty to defend was triggered by a landowner’s trespass and nuisance claims against a railroad maintenance contractor, alleging that the construction of a water diversion system caused an invasion onto his property.

The court held these claims were arguably within the policy’s personal and advertising injury coverage provision for wrongful eviction, wrongful entry, or invasion of right to privacy.

As reflected in the cases cited above, courts everywhere have struggled with the scope and application of the liability coverage afforded for personal and advertising injury. Because of the legalistic nature of the listed offenses and exclusions, coverage questions involving these claims tend to be hyper-technical and fact-intensive. There is no shortage of reported opinions or articles discussing the various offenses and exclusions, in exhaustive detail.

However, the first step to exploiting the benefits of personal and advertising injury coverage is to understand that it exists. So, the next time you find yourself on either side of a dispute involving an intentional tort or other invasion of the rights of another, it may be well worth your time to revisit this coverage.

Endnotes

  1. A standard form liability insurance policy generally excludes coverage for intentional injury, i.e., bodily injury or property damage “intended or expected from the perspective of the insured.” See, e.g., ISO Commercial Liability Coverage Form CG 00 01 04 13 at p. 2. Intentional acts and intentional injury are different concepts.

  2. Id. at p. 1.

  3. Id. at p. 13.

  4. Id., at p. 5. (Some other forms, including ISO’s 1993 CGL form, make separate reference to “personal injury” and “advertising injury.”)

  5. Id. at p. 15.

  6. “Advertisement” means a notice that is broadcast or published to the general public or specific market segments about the insured’s goods, products or services for the purpose of attracting customers or supporters, including material published on the Internet or by other, similar means. Id. at p. 13.

  7. Id. at pp. 6-7.