Kansas Supreme Court Delivers Clarity to Worker Misclassification
By Sean McGivern and Tim Sipe
Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Association for Justice, Vol. 38 (January 2015). This article reflects the law as of that date.
Independent contractor misclassification persists throughout the American economy.[2] It occurs when companies carry out their affairs not through employees, but through others who are just as economically dependent. In Craig v. FedEx Ground Package Systems, Inc.,[3] the Kansas Supreme Court recently confronted the issue head on, holding that FedEx misclassified its Kansas delivery drivers as independent contractors. This article summarizes the recent court decision and places it in the larger context of worker rights advocacy.
Background and Adverse Consequences of Independent Contractor Misclassification
When a restaurant hires a plumber to work on its water heater, the plumber serves as an independent contractor. The restaurant does not tell the plumber how to do his job. No one expects the restaurant to pay the plumber’s health insurance premiums and employment taxes. How about the deliverymen who transport supplies to the restaurant? They work for a third party and deliver supplies to many restaurants and businesses, not just one. The deliverymen are independent contractors; they are not employees of the countless businesses to which they deliver goods.
But what about a cook at a restaurant? He is not a contractor, he is an employee of the restaurant.[4] Yet thousands of businesses classify their employees as contractors every day in America. These decisions are not benign. By misclassifying employees as independent contractors, employers evade many legal obligations, including:
Minimum wage;
Overtime compensation;
Benefits otherwise available to employees, including retirement plans, insurance, and paid time off;
Applicability of many civil rights laws;
Laws requiring the timely payment of wages, and curtailing an employer’s ability to withhold or set-off debts from an employee’s wages;
Payroll taxes and other employment taxes;
Contributions to unemployment insurance; and
Contributions to workers compensation insurance.
Collectively, misclassification costs taxing authorities hundreds of millions of dollars per year.[5] The problem persists despite various civil ramifications for the perpetrators; for example, Kansas makes knowing and intentional misclassification a crime.[6]
Misclassification is not limited to small businesses or fly-by-night concerns. It occurs frequently with people employed as information technology professionals, Internet and telecommunications experts, marketing specialists, copywriters, analysts, and workers with specialized technical or professional skills.[7] And it occurs disproportionately in jobs dealing with construction, real estate, home care, trucking, janitorial, and high tech industry.[8]
Employers are aware that they may be scrutinized for classifying their workers as independent contractors. Therefore, many employers attempt to structure their relationships to appear, superficially, as contractor relationships and not employment relationships. In Craig, the Kansas Supreme Court reinforced the court’s task to evaluate the substance of these relationships in determining whether workers are, in fact, independent contractors.
Craig Comes to Kansas Through Certified Questions From the FedEx MDL
Craig is part of a long-running multidistrict litigation in the Northern District of Indiana that consists of various misclassification suits brought by drivers against FedEx.[9] It came to the Kansas Supreme Court in July 2012, when the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit certified two questions about the meaning of the term “employee” in the Kansas Wage Payment Act (KWPA).[10]
The Seventh Circuit’s certification arose from the MDL District Court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of FedEx, which held, as a matter of law, that 479 Kansas drivers were independent contractors and not “employees” within the meaning of the KWPA.[11] The drivers appealed to the Seventh Circuit. On appeal, the Seventh Circuit requested the Kansas Supreme Court’s guidance as to the “underlying principle (or principles) that guides the weighing process in close cases such as this seeking to establish an employment relationship under the KWPA.”[12] As framed by Kansas’s highest court, “The simple question is whether FedEx’s delivery drivers are employees” pursuant to K.S.A. 44-313(b).[13]
The Court Synthesizes the Framework for Analyzing Contractor vs. Employee Classification
The Seventh Circuit and the Kansas Supreme Court considered three tests inconsistently applied by Kansas courts. Kansas state courts routinely applied both the “right to control” test[14] and a “20-factor” test.[15] Moreover, the majority of circuits were utilizing a third test when analyzing the employer-employee relationship under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).[16] The Court was thus tasked with picking the appropriate test or, in the alternative, synthesizing three.
Under the most labor-intensive of the three, the 20-factor test requires weighing various factors to determine whether each supports an employer-employee or independent contractor relationship.[17] The factors are:
1. The employer’s right to require compliance with instructions;
2. The extent of any training provided by the employer;
3. The degree of integration of the worker’s services into the business of the employer;
4. The requirement that services be provided personally by the worker;
5. The extent to which the worker hires, supervises, and pays assistants;
6. The existence of a continuing relationship between the worker and the employer;
7. The employer’s establishment of set work hours;
8. The requirement that the worker devote full time to the employer’s business;
9. The degree to which the work is performed on the employer’s premises;
10. The degree to which the employer sets the order and sequence of work;
11. The requirement that the worker submit regular or written reports to the employer;
12. The manner of payment to the worker, e.g., by the hour, day, or job;
13. The extent to which the employer pays the worker’s business or travel expenses;
14. The degree to which the employer furnishes tools, equipment, and material;
15. The incurrence of significant investment by the worker;
16. The ability of the worker to make a profit or suffer a loss;
17. Whether the worker can work for more than one firm at a time;
18. Whether the worker makes his or her services available to the general public on a regular and consistent basis;
19. Whether the employer has the right to discharge the worker; and
20. Whether the worker has the right to terminate the relationship at any time without incurring liability.[18]
Recognizing that some of these factors seem duplicative, the Court formally incorporated the descriptions of each factor found in IRS Revenue Ruling 87-41.[19] The IRS’ explanation of each factor emphasizes that control is the key inquiry. Consider, for example, the IRS’ explanation of the integration factor:
Integration of the worker’s services into the business operations generally shows that the worker is subject to direction and control. When the success or continuation of a business depends to an appreciable degree upon the performance of certain services, the workers who perform those services must necessarily be subject to a certain amount of control by the owner of the business.[20]
Next, the Court confirmed the Seventh Circuit’s observation that Kansas places a special emphasis on the right-to-control test in determining employee status.[21] After reviewing the specifics of the 20-factor test with an eye for factors implicating the right to control, the Court concluded the 20 factors encompassed sufficient elements of the right-to-control test.[22] The Court’s desire to maintain the emphasis on the right-to-control test was evident in its analysis.[23] Thus, the 20-factor test would be an appropriate framework under the existing Kansas common law.
The Court then addressed the effect of the prevailing federal analysis of employment status under the FLSA: the economic realities test.[24] The economic realities analysis seeks “to look past technical, common-law concepts of the master-servant relationship to determine whether, as a matter of economic reality, a worker is dependent on a given employer.”[25] This test analyzes:
(1) the degree of control exerted by the alleged employer over the worker; (2) the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss; (3) the worker’s investment in the business; (4) the permanence of the working relationship; (5) the degree of skill required to perform the work; and (6) the extent to which the work is an integral part of the alleged employer’s business.[26]
The Court was not inclined to jettison the 20-factor test in favor of the FLSA’s economic realities test because the latter alone would negate the emphasis on the right to control.[27] On the other hand, the two tests are not entirely inconsistent. With the exception of the worker’s degree of skill, the Court noted all other factors of the economic realities test were adequately represented in the 20-factor analysis.[28]
With a nod to Kansas precedent emphasizing the importance of the right to control test, the Court “reformatted” the 20-factor test to indicate which factors simultaneously address factors from the economic realities test. For example, the first factor in the 20-factor test now reads “(1) the employer’s right to require compliance with instructions (economic reality test’s degree of control factor).”[29] Otherwise the 20-factor test, with its emphasis on the right to control, prevails in Kansas.
Armed with the newly clarified analytical framework, the Court weighed the 20 factors against the voluminous undisputed facts before them.
Are FedEx Drivers Employees or Independent Contractors?
At its core, Craig turns on a carefully constructed Operating Agreement (OA) that FedEx required its newly hired drivers to execute.[30] Wielding the 20-factor test with an eye toward FedEx’s right to control, the Court spent ample time addressing its perceived “micromanagement” exercised by FedEx over its delivery drivers.[31] This micromanagement was apparent in analyzing many of the 20 factors.[32]
With respect to FedEx’s right to require compliance with instructions under the first factor, the undisputed facts showed that failure to comply with any number of the specific requirements of the OA would be grounds for termination.[33] Specifically, the OA required drivers to adhere to FedEx standards relating to driver appearance, vehicle maintenance, and vehicle appearance.[34] While FedEx argued those standards served only to provide their customers with a sense of security in opening their homes to drivers displaying the FedEx brand, the Court flatly disagreed, stating “the notion that such requirements are merely unenforceable suggestions is negated by the fact that FedEx reserves the right to refuse to allow a driver to perform his or her deliveries if the driver is not properly dressed or groomed.”[35]
While FedEx argued that the requirements placed on drivers were only intended to achieve FedEx’s desired result and not the means of or methods involved, “FedEx’s conduct spoke louder than its words.”[36] As such, the Court found the extent and specificity in which FedEx monitored its drivers and strict enforcement of the OA weigh in favor of an employer-employee relationship.[37]
Including the first factor, the Court found 11 of the 20 factors weighed in favor of an employer-employee relationship.[38] With respect to some of the other facts relevant to the 11 factors, the Court found: (1) FedEx encouraged a long and continuous relationship by providing bonuses based on a driver’s time with the company and tied its leave program, in part, on seniority;[39] (2) the goal of a FedEx manager determining the number of packages to be delivered in a given day was to assign between nine to eleven hours of work per driver, thus rendering full-time service all but mandatory;[40] (3) FedEx’s requirements to purchase certain equipment, tools, uniforms, or other materials greatly limited a driver’s ability to control “expenses” so as to allow him or her to impact profits;[41] and (4) the OA specifically provided for a driver’s right to terminate the relationship upon 30 days’ notice, and as such, the undisputed evidence showed no adverse financial implications for drivers who exercised this option.[42]
However, the Court also found six of the 20 factors to weigh in favor of finding an independent contractor relationship.[43] With respect to some of the facts supporting those factors, the Court found: (1) drivers could have hired others to perform their duties despite the requirement that FedEx approve those individuals;[44] (2) drivers were responsible for all costs associated with their vehicles including taxes and insurance in addition to uniforms and package tracking equipment;[45] and (3) drivers often incurred significant expense purchasing many of the required items.[46]
Finally, the Court found two of the 20 factors to be neutral or to “cut both ways.”[47] Contrary to FedEx Home Delivery v. National Labor Relations Board,[48] the Kansas Supreme Court was careful to note that when considering factors cutting both ways “we place particular emphasis on the company’s right to control the worker to tip the scales.”[49] Viewing the evidence as a whole, the Court had little issue finding that FedEx entered into an employment relationship with its drivers “but dressed that relationship in independent contractor clothing.”[50] Thus, the drivers were held to be employees within the meaning of the KWPA.
Both the Seventh Circuit and the District Court agreed this was a close call.[51] However, neither addressed the fact that this was precisely FedEx’s intent in drafting the OAs. The Kansas Supreme Court’s unsympathetic tone can be explained by FedEx’s admission that it “carefully structured the company’s operating agreements so that it could label the drivers as independent contractors in order to gain a competitive advantage, i.e., to avoid the additional costs associated with employees.”[52] The Court “consider[ed] the manner in which FedEx implemented the OA to be a compelling factor in determining the substantive question of the company’s right to control its drivers.”[53]
The Kansas Supreme Court went one step further and held, in response to the second certified question, that “the employer/employee relationship between FedEx and a full-time delivery driver with respect to the assigned service area is not terminated or altered when the driver acquires an additional route for which he or she is not the driver.”[54]
Takeaways From Craig Include an Uptick in Workers’ Rights Litigation
There are many takeaways from the Craig decision. It reminds everyone that the freedom to contract is not absolute, and it may be restrained by laws governing the employment relationship.[55] Many companies do not agree with paying workers compensation insurance, overtime, and benefits. But the desire to save money does not allow businesses to “opt out” of the law.
Craig therefore reinforces the point that substance, and not form, governs the review of employee classification. The Court’s emphasis on who structured the relationship, and why, will be of paramount importance in misclassification litigation. The contractor agreements that businesses require their workers to sign will no longer protect businesses from liability. In fact, they may weigh in favor of liability.
As a result of misclassification, employers can be held liable for violations of the KWPA, including its strict prohibitions against withholding of wages.[56] Though the Kansas Supreme Court did not expressly apply the FLSA’s economic-realities test, the Court accounted for all but one of its elements into the reformulated 20-factor test.[57] Therefore, employees have a strong argument that employee status under the KWPA indicates employee status under the FLSA. That translates into claims for unpaid overtime and, in some cases, minimum wages. Finally, as misclassified independent contractors, employees may be able to pursue state law claims for the value of unpaid benefits like health insurance and 401(k) contributions.[58]
Craig is a victory for employees in Kansas. The decision is not self-executing, however. Expect to see an uptick in misclassification cases alleging violations of applicable state and federal laws in light of Craig.
The authors thank Joseph A. Schremmer for his editorial assistance.
Endnotes
U.S. Dep’t of Labor, Employee Misclassification as Independent Contractors (last checked Nov. 30, 2014).
335 P.3d 66, 72 (Kan. 2014) (per curiam).
See Lang v. Landeros, 918 P.2d 404 (Okla. 1996).
Mandy Locke, For Many Workers Cheated Out of Wages, NC Department of Labor Offers No Help, The Charlotte Observer, Nov. 12, 2014 (estimating lost North Carolina tax revenue at $467 million per year).
Kan. Stat. Ann. § 44-766.
Pepper Hamilton Law Firm, Independent Contractor Misclassification Update 2012: How Companies Can Minimize the Risks (May 14, 2012).
Nat’l Emp. L. Project, Independent Contractor Misclassification Imposes Huge Costs on Workers and Federal and State Treasuries (Aug. 2014).
In re FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., No. 05-MD-527 (N.D. Ind.).
Craig v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 686 F.3d 423 (7th Cir. 2012).
Id.; In re FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 734 F. Supp. 2d 557 (N.D. Ind. 2010).
Craig, 686 F.3d at 428.
Craig v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 335 P.3d 66, 72 (Kan. 2014) (per curiam).
Jones v. City of Dodge City, 194 Kan. 777, 780, 402 P.2d 108 (1965); Craig, 335 P.3d at 74.
Crawford v. Kan. Dep’t of Human Res., 17 Kan. App. 2d 707, 845 P.2d 703 (1989).
29 U.S.C. § 201, et seq.; Johnson v. Unified Gov’t of Wyandotte, 371 F.3d 723, 727-28 (10th Cir. 2004); Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc., 703 F.3d 497, 506 (10th Cir. 2012).
Craig, 335 P.3d 66, 80 (Kan. 2014).
Id. at 76. While Crawford articulated factors 19 and 20 in slightly different terms, the Supreme Court in Craig resolved any ambiguity by clarifying factor 20 was whether the employee had the right to terminate the relationship, not the employer.
Craig, 335 P.3d at 74 (citing Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296).
Rev. Rul. 87-41, 1987-1 C.B. 296 (citations omitted).
Craig, 335 P.3d at 74 (citing Jones v. City of Dodge City, 194 Kan. 777, 780, 402 P.2d 108 (1965)) (“The primary test used by the courts in determining whether an employer-employee relationship exists is whether the employer has the right of control and supervision over the work of the alleged employee, and the right to direct the manner in which the work is to be performed, as well as the result which is to be accomplished”); Craig v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 686 F.3d 423, 427–28 (7th Cir. 2012).
Craig, 335 P.3d 66, 75-76.
Id.
Id. at 75.
Id. (citing Barlow v. C.R. England, Inc., 703 F.3d 497, 506 (10th Cir. 2012)).
Craig, 335 P.3d 66, 75 (citing Barlow, at 506).
Craig, 335 P.3d at 76.
Id. at 75–76.
Id. at 76.
Id. at 81.
See id. at 81 (citing Estrada v. FedEx Ground Package System, Inc., 154 Cal. App. 4th 1, 9, 64 Cal. Rptr. 3d 327 (2007) (“FedEx endeavors to control every exquisite detail of the drivers’ performance, including the color of their socks and the style of their hair”)).
Id. at 84–85.
Id. at 81.
Id. at 81–82.
Id.
Id. at 81.
Id. at 85.
Id. at 76 (see “20-factor” test factors: 1, 3, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12, 16, 17, 18, 20).
Id. at 87.
Id. at 88.
Id. at 90-91.
Id. at 92.
Id. at 76 (see “20-factor” test factors: 4, 5, 10, 13, 14, 15, 19).
Id. at 86.
Id. at 89-90.
Id.
Id. at 76 (see “20-factor” test factors: 2, 9).
FedEx Home Delivery v. Nat’l Labor Relations Bd., 563 F.3d 492 (D.C. Cir. 2009) (holding when factors cut both ways, the governing principle was whether the position presented opportunities and risks inherent in entrepreneurialism).
Craig, 335 P.3d at 80.
Id. at 92.
Craig v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 686 F.3d 423, 429 (7th Cir. 2012); see In re FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., 734 F. Supp. 2d 557, 560, 600-01 (N.D. Ind. 2010).
Craig, 335 P.3d at 72-73 (emphasis added).
Id. at 76.
Craig, 335 P.3d 66 at 93.
W. Coast Hotel Co. v. Parrish, 300 U.S. 379, 392-93 (1937) (“This power under the Constitution to restrict freedom of contract has had many illustrations. That it may be exercised in the public interest with respect to contracts between employer and employee is undeniable.”).
Kan. Stat. Ann. § 44-319; see also Boyd A. Byers, Keeping Up with the Kansas Wage Payment Act, 83 J. Kan. B. Ass’n at 28-29 (Oct. 2014).
Craig, 335 P.3d at 76.
Gray v. FedEx Ground Package Sys., Inc., No. 4:06-CV-00422 JAR, 2014 WL 4386741, at *1 (E.D. Mo. Sept. 5, 2014) (holding ERISA does not preempt claim by misclassified contractors for the value of unpaid benefits).