The Insurance “Renewal Rule” — Avoiding Latent Changes in Renewal Policies
By N. Russell Hazlewood
Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Association for Justice, Vol. 38 (September 2014). This article reflects the law as of that date.
Is it possible to establish coverage under an insurance policy for loss or liability that is clearly and unequivocally excluded? Under the right circumstances, it is.
Last year, we filed a first-party suit against a homeowner’s insurer for failure to defend or indemnify its insured, a young woman, from suit for bodily injury arising from her use of a motorized bicycle that collided with a motorcycle. The passenger of the motorcycle was severely injured. At trial, she had obtained a net judgment against our client for more than $861,000, even though our client’s personal defense counsel established that the other driver was 60% at fault. Our client spent more than $12,500 in attorneys’ fees to provide her own defense.
We believed our client’s homeowner’s insurer breached its policy contract by refusing to defend or indemnify her from the suit. Although K.S.A. § 40-2404(9)(n) required the insurer to “promptly provide a reasonable explanation of the basis in the insurance policy in relation to the facts or applicable law for denial of [the] claim … ,” it did not. Its disclaimer letters were ambiguous and, in some instances, unintelligible. However, it appeared to us that the homeowner’s insurer was relying on an exclusion for liability coverage for bodily injury or property damage arising from the ownership, maintenance, or use of a “motor vehicle.”
The term “motor vehicle” was not defined in the homeowner’s policy. Applying rules of construction favoring coverage in the face of ambiguity, as well as statutory definitions,[1] we believed we could establish that a motorized bicycle is not a motor vehicle, and the exclusion in the homeowner’s policy was inapplicable. (Curiously, the same insurer had also denied coverage under our client’s automobile liability policy, claiming in that instance her motorized bicycle was not a “motor vehicle”).
After we filed suit to enforce the homeowner’s policy, the insurer for the first time, through its counsel, raised an endorsement to the policy as the basis or reason for denying liability insurance coverage to our client. That endorsement, which was not attached to our copy of the policy (but which, I had to admit, was identified in the policy declarations) purported to amend the policy to include an express exclusion for liability coverage for bodily injury or property damage resulting from the operation of a motorized bicycle! It appeared we were dead in the water.
Rather than admitting defeat, we conducted some discovery and requested a copy of the endorsement, which we had never seen. We also requested the renewal paperwork that accompanied the endorsement and any written notices, issued prior to renewal, explaining the new reduction in liability coverage.
Upon reviewing the materials we received, we learned that the endorsement had been added to the policy at renewal, about 10 years prior to the subject accident. However, to the surprise of the insurer and its counsel, we concluded the plainly stated, longstanding exclusion was ineffective against our client’s claim, because of the insurance “renewal rule.”
After we invoked the “renewal rule,” the insurer folded its hand. It made a six-figure payment in full satisfaction of the injured claimant’s judgment against our client, agreed to reimburse our client for all of her defense costs with interest, and agreed to confess judgment for the costs of the coverage action, including a reasonable attorney’s fee, in an amount to be determined by the district court. From our client’s perspective, no better result was possible.
The “Renewal Rule”
Generally, an insured has some obligation to review and understand an insurance policy.[2] An insurance policy is a contract. In most instances, “failure to read a contract does not make the contract less binding.”[3] However, these general rules apply only to “original, newly issued policies.”[4] The courts treat renewal policies differently.
“The insured’s affirmative duty to review the terms of the original policy does not extend to a renewal policy that has been modified.”[5] Absent notice to the contrary, an insured has a right to assume that the terms of the renewed policy are the same as those of the expiring policy.[6] That is because courts recognize it would be “inequitable to require an insured to search the fine print of each renewal policy.”[7] Instead, “when an insurer renews a previously issued policy, it has an affirmative duty to provide adequate notice to the insured of changes in coverage.”[8] Failure to provide such notice will render the changes voidable.
In Government Employees’ Insurance Company v. United States, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals succinctly stated the “renewal rule” as follows:
While the renewal of an insurance policy constitutes a separate contract to be governed by general contract principles, it is the general rule that an insurance company is bound by the greater coverage in an earlier policy where the renewal contract is issued without calling to the insured’s attention a reduction in policy coverage.[9]
In Campbell v. Insurance Service Agency, the Minnesota Court of Appeals described the renewal rule as follows:
[W]hen an insurer, by renewal of a policy or by an endorsement to an existing policy, substantially reduces the prior coverage provided the insured, the insurer has an affirmative duty to notify the insured by written explanation of the change in coverage. Failure to do so will render void the purported reduction in coverage.[10]
A host of other jurisdictions have similarly described and applied the renewal rule, which appears to be ubiquitous.[11] The renewal rule has also been codified in some jurisdictions.[12]
The renewal rule is grounded in the law of reformation rather than estoppel.[13] Consequently, its application should be unimpaired by the general rule that estoppel will not expand a policy’s coverage.[14]
In Amway Distributors Benefits Association v. Northfield Insurance Company, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals stated that an excess carrier with a following form policy will be bound by the primary insurer’s failure to comply with the “renewal rule.”[15]
Form of Notice
The case law suggests notice will be adequate only when it reasonably calls a reduction in coverage to the insured’s attention. In Koski v. Allstate Insurance Company, the Michigan Court of Appeals held that the sufficiency of notice of a reduction in coverage is a question of law for the court.[16] The court held that a letter indicating that the policy had been revised and imploring the insured to “take a few minutes to read [his] new policy” did not meet the standard — especially where the letter emphasized favorable amendments but failed to mention any exclusion.[17] The court further found that a single, unemphasized reference to the reduction in coverage in a 12-page booklet that accompanied the letter was insufficient to alert the insured of the change.[18]
Another court similarly found that a written admonition to “read the [renewal] policy carefully” was insufficient to inform the insured that advertising injury coverage had been reduced.[19]
In most circumstances, merely enclosing an endorsement with the renewal documents would not satisfy the renewal rule’s notice requirement, as the insured has no legal duty to read the policy without first being alerted of a change.[20] However, in Government Employees Insurance Co. v. United States, the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals held an insured had been sufficiently notified where the renewal policy was transmitted with a short, separately attached, and boldly worded modifying endorsement, along with instructions to the insured to read it carefully.[21] In any event, the cases indicate that a prudent insurer should provide the insured with a written explanation notifying the insured that the endorsement will substantially reduce the policy’s coverage and explaining the nature of the reduction.
Practical Application
In our case, the insurer did send a notice to the insured explaining that various coverages under the homeowner’s policy would change at renewal. It called attention to the fact that liability insurance and property insurance for loss caused by or arising out of, or consisting of mold, fungus, wet rot, dry rot, and bacteria would no longer be covered. However, we found nothing independent of the modifying endorsement itself that called attention to or explained the fact that the expiring policy’s liability insurance exclusion for “bodily injury or property damage arising out of the ownership, maintenance, use, occupancy, renting, loaning, entrusting, loading or unloading of any motor vehicle or trailer” was being expanded also to exclude coverage for motorized bicycles. That purported exclusion was effected by insertion of the words “or motorized bicycle,” in small type, in an exclusion on page 7 of an 8-page endorsement that was enclosed among 51 total pages of renewal documents. The change was not emphasized in any way.
Consequently, we made a convincing case that the insurer’s renewal paperwork did not sufficiently alert the insured to the purported reduction in coverage, and so it was void. In that process, we obtained a fully compensatory recovery for our client; and we established our client’s right to recover an attorney’s fee for our services. In addition, our lawsuit helped a brother in the trial bar collect a significant judgment for his client, the severely injured motorcycle passenger.
The renewal rule can be an effective arrow in the quiver of the insurance recovery trial lawyer. Properly wielded, it just might help you establish coverage for your client where it appears there is none.
Endnotes
See, e.g., K.S.A. § 8-126(t) (stating that “motor vehicle” means every vehicle, other than a motorized bicycle or a motorized wheelchair, which is self-propelled) (emphasis added).
Jones v. Reliable Sec., Inc, 29 Kan. App. 2d 617, Syl. ¶ 12, 28 P.3d 1051 (2001).
Liggatt v. Employers Mut. Cas. Co., 273 Kan. 915, 921, 46 P.3d 1120, 1125 (2002); but see Rider v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 514 F.2d 780, 783 (10th Cir. 1975) (“[I]n Kansas the insured may assume that an insurance policy will conform to the application. The insured may rely on this assumption, and is under no duty to read the policy to see whether it does in fact conform.”) (citing Stamps v. Consol. Underwriters, 205 Kan. 187, 468 P.2d 84 (1970) and German Amer. Ins. Co. v. Darrin, 80 Kan. 578, 103 P. 87 (1909)).
Perry v. Econ. Fire & Cas. Co., 724 N.E.2d 151, 152 (Ill. App. 1999).
Id.
Marchesano v. Nationwide Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co., 506 So. 2d 410, 413 (Fla. 1987) (citing May v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 430 So. 2d 999, 1001 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1983)); accord Bauman v. Royal Indem. Co., 174 A.2d 585, 592 (N.J. 1961); Gov’t Emp. Ins. Co. v. Ropka, 536 A.2d 1214 (Md. 1988) (quoting Couch on Insurance 2d, § 68.6).
Gov’t Emp. Ins. Co. v. U.S., 400 F.2d 172, 175 (10th Cir. 1968).
Thomas v. NW. Nat. Ins. Co., 973 P.2d 804, 807 (Mont. 1998); accord Perry, 724 N.E.2d at 152.
400 F.2d 172, 174-175.
424 N.W.2d 785, 790 (Minn. Ct. App. 1988).
See, e.g., Metro. Bus. Mgmt., Inc. v. Allstate Ins. Co., 448 Fed. Appx. 677 (9th Cir. 2011) (“[I]nsurance companies are bound by a greater coverage in an earlier policy when a renewal policy is issued but the insured is not notified of the specific reduction in coverage”) (applying California law; internal quotations omitted); Koski v. Allstate Ins. Co., 539 N.W.2d 561, 563. (Mich. App. 1995), rev’d on other grounds 572 N.W.2d 636 (1998); Gov’t Emp. Ins. Co. v. Ropka, 536 A.2d at 1223 (“Most jurisdictions impose an affirmative duty on the insurer to make the insured aware of changes inserted into a renewal policy; absent notice of the change, the insured is entitled to coverage as the original policy stated.”) (citing Couch on Insurance 2d, § 68.61).
See, e.g., Mont. Code Ann. § 33–15–1106(1) (“If an insurer offers or purports to renew a policy but on less favorable terms, at a higher rate, or at a higher rating plan, the new terms, rate, or rating plan take effect on the policy renewal date only if the insurer has mailed or delivered notice of the new terms, rate, or rating plan to the insured at least 30 days before the expiration date.”); Colo. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 10-4-110.5 (also requiring notice of “reasons” for reduction in coverage).
Am. Cas. Co. v. Glaskin, 805 F. Supp. 866, 872 (D. Colo. 1992) (quoting 3 Corbin on Contracts § 614, n. 21 (1960) (“It is reasonable for the insured to assume without reading that a ‘renewal’ policy is just like the policy that is expiring. If the renewal policy contains an added provision, or omits a provision, reformation is proper.”)); Amway Distrib. Benefits Ass’n v. Northfield Ins. Co., 323 F.3d 386, 393 (6th Cir. 2003) (rejecting insurer’s assertion that remedy was grounded in estoppel based on “numerous cases that have applied the rule with no discussion of estoppel”).
See Allied Mut. Ins. Co. v. Moeder, 30 Kan. App. 2d 729, Syl. ¶ 6, 48 P. 3d 1 (2002).
Amway Distrib. Benefits Ass’n, 323 F.3d 386 at 393.
539 N.W.2d at 563.
Id.
Id.
Amway Distrib. Benefits Ass’n, 990 F. Supp. at 942.
Am. Cas. Co. v. Rhan, 854 F. Supp. 492, 502 (W.D. Mich. 1994).
Gov’t Emp. Ins. Co. v. U.S., 400 F.2d at 175.