Advocating for You in Court and Beyond Team Up With Us
Cover of the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, March 2017 issue

Federal Law Roundup: Whistleblower Statutes, ERISA Liens, and New Regulations

March 2017 March 1, 2017

By Sean McGivern & Donald N. Peterson II

Originally published in the Journal of the Kansas Trial Lawyers Association, Vol. 40 (March 2017). This article reflects the law as of that date.

As two of the few KTLA attorneys who handle employment law and ERISA matters, we get our fair share of questions. Below are federal topics that come up in our conversations with our KTLA peers. It is our hope that this information will add a new arrow to your quiver!

1. AIR 21

The FAA regulates aviation safety. Employees of an “air carrier” or a contractor to an air carrier are protected from retaliation for insisting that federal regulations relating to aircraft safety are followed. This protection arises from the Wendell H. Ford Aviation Investment and Reform Act for the 21st Century, which was enacted on April 5, 2000. The law is popularly referred to as “AIR 21.”

AIR 21 cases are adjudicated by the United States Department of Labor (DOL). The first step is filing a claim with the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) within 90 days of the adverse action. An expeditious OSHA investigation process yields initial findings. Either side may appeal the findings to the DOL’s Office of Administrative Law Judges for a de novo trial on the merits. Employees need only prove that their protected activity was a contributing factor in the adverse action; after that the employer bears the burden of establishing, by clear and convincing evidence, that they would have taken the same adverse action in the absence of the protected activity. These cases can result in awards of reinstatement, back pay, front pay, compensatory damages, and attorney fees.

The DOL forum for AIR 21 cases is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it is a favorable forum because the DOL sees this law to be an important component to ensuring aircraft safety. DOL therefore takes these cases very seriously and is disinclined to accept evasive defense strategies during discovery. On the other hand, this forum is difficult because the ALJ typically is far from Kansas and extremely knowledgeable of FAA regulations. This distance can make case management a bit trickier. And there is a tendency to get bogged down into the minutia of FAA regulations. The last case we handled resulted in a 75-page, single-spaced decision. We won, but the amount of detail was mind boggling.

Appeals from AIR 21 findings are heard by a superior court within DOL called the Administrative Review Board. Further appeals are to the relevant federal circuit court.

2. Other OSHA Whistleblower Laws

AIR 21 is one of many anti-retaliation laws enforced through DOL. OSHA’s Whistleblower Protection Program enforces the whistleblower provisions of more than 20 statutes protecting employees who report violations of various workplace safety and health, airline, commercial motor carrier, consumer product, environmental, financial reform (Sarbanes-Oxley; Dodd-Frank), food safety, health insurance reform, motor vehicle safety, nuclear, pipeline, public transportation agency, railroad, maritime, and securities laws.

Check out www.whistleblowers.gov for information about these laws, their enforcement mechanisms (in some cases, the aggrieved employee may “kick out” to federal court and proceed under relaxed evidentiary standards unknown to both the common law and the conventional civil rights laws), and relevant limitations periods. The relatively short limitations period is the main disadvantage of these laws.

Section 11(c) of the Occupational Safety and Health Act is the original whistleblower law enforced by OSHA. This law prohibits employers from discriminating against their employees for exercising rights protected by the OSH Act. Such rights include making an OSHA complaint, speaking with OSHA investigators, and even reporting a work injury. This is important as many people who report work injuries lose their jobs. If workers have been retaliated or discriminated against for exercising their Section 11(c) rights, they must file a complaint with OSHA within 30 days of the alleged adverse action. After an investigation, the Secretary of Labor can file an action in federal district court to redress the retaliation.

Whistleblower complaints may be filed with any OSHA office or online. We have found the OSHA investigation process to be helpful in representing our clients. OSHA makes employer position statements and correspondence available to the employee’s counsel. The investigation process is much quicker than the EEOC or the Kansas Human Rights Commission process. By the time that OSHA issues initial findings on the complaint, there is a case file of documents and recorded statements available through a FOIA request (with certain exceptions). This helps us size up the cases, early, at minimum expense.

3. National Defense Authorization Act

Buried deep in the pages of the 2013 National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) is a powerful cause of action to protect whistleblowers who report on fraud and abuse in the administration of government contracts and grants. 41 U.S.C. § 4712. The law was part of a pilot program; in December 2016, the law was made permanent.

NDAA protects all individuals performing work on a government contract or grant (whether as a contractor, as an employee, as a contractor of a contractor, etc.) from reprisal for disclosing information that the individual reasonably believes is evidence of gross mismanagement of a grant or contract; a gross waste of federal funds; an abuse of authority relating to a contract or grant; a substantial and specific danger to public health or safety; or a violation of a law, rule, or regulation related to the grant or contract. Disclosure to federal officials, courts, grand juries, inspectors general, and similar authority is protected. Significantly, disclosure to “a management official or other employee of the contractor, subcontractor, or grantee who has the responsibility to investigate, discover, or address misconduct” is also protected.

The NDAA anti-retaliation law imposes a low threshold of proof. The relevant standard is “contributing factor,” while the employer’s same decision defense requires proof by clear and convincing evidence. This proof scheme reflects the significant public interests protected by NDAA. Enforcement of NDAA’s anti-retaliation provision occurs by filing a complaint with the relevant department’s inspector general, who is required to investigate the complaint and issue findings. The complaint must be filed with the inspector general not more than three years after the retaliation occurred. NDAA has a “kick out” provision that permits the complainant to file in federal district court and proceed under relaxed proof standards if the inspector general has not resolved the complaint within 210 days. Remedies under NDAA are robust.

4. ERISA Liens

ERISA reimbursement rights are a source of problems for many lawyers in the personal injury arena. These rights, of course, arise under the terms of an ERISA-governed benefit plan. Reimbursement issues are usually resolved fairly and amicably. However, fiduciaries and plan administrators may enforce reimbursement rights through 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3), which permits civil suits to obtain “appropriate equitable relief” to enforce the terms of the plan.

Kansas insurance regulations prohibit insurance companies from using subrogation clauses (or other clauses with a similar purpose or effect) in their policies. K.A.R. 40-1-20. This regulation is a valid exercise of the state’s authority to regulate insurance, and therefore saved from ERISA preemption. Often confusion arises as to the regulation’s application because self-funded plans hire insurance companies to administer benefits. Self-funded benefit plans are not insurance companies, and they are not subject to state insurance regulations. Therefore, it is not safe to assume that the anti-subrogation regulation applies because the client has a Blue Cross Blue Shield insurance card. Specific written demand must be made on the employer and the carrier to ascertain whether the plan is self-funded or insured.

In today’s world, many employers choose to fund their medical plans with a combination of employer and employee contributions, and to purchase “stop loss” coverage. Medical stop loss is an insurance product that provides protection against catastrophic or unpredictable losses, so that employers do not have to assume 100% of the losses on large claims. The question often arises whether a self-funded plan with stop loss coverage is subject to K.A.R. 40-1-20’s proscription against subrogation provisions. The Kansas federal court held in 2004 that Walmart’s medical plan, which was self-funded but operated by an insurance company and protected by a stop-loss policy, was not subject to K.A.R. 40-1-20 because it qualified as a self-funded plan. Admin. Comm. of Wal-Mart Assocs. Health & Welfare Plan v. Willard, 302 F. Supp. 2d 1267, 1283 (D. Kan.), aff’d, 393 F.3d 1119 (10th Cir. 2004). This is more incentive for counsel to get to the bottom of reimbursement issues well before settling a PI case with substantial liens.

On a separate note, the Tenth Circuit held in 2015 that the Federal Employees Health Benefit Act preempts K.A.R. 40-1-20. Helfrich v. Blue Cross & Blue Shield Ass’n, 804 F.3d 1090 (10th Cir. 2015). Carriers who issue policies under FEHBA therefore claim reimbursement from PI recoveries with impunity. The United States Supreme Court recently granted certiorari in Coventry Health Care of Missouri, Inc. v. Nevil, to address whether FEHBA preempts state laws that prohibit insurance companies from claiming the proceeds of personal injury settlements pursuant to their contracts. Don’t hold your breath on this one.

There have been some interesting developments in the world of medical reimbursement. The trend throughout the 2000s and into the early 2010s gave wide latitude to plans to pursue equitable reimbursement claims. The United States Supreme Court halted that trend in 2016, holding “when a participant dissipates the whole [PI] settlement on nontraceable items, the fiduciary cannot bring a suit to attach the participant’s general assets under [29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3)] because the suit is not one for ‘appropriate equitable relief.’” Montanile v. Bd. of Trustees of Nat. Elevator Indus. Health Benefit Plan, 136 S. Ct. 651 (2016). This holding is right on the law. However, many large law firms now advocate that employers and administrators should act earlier and more aggressively to protect their reimbursement rights.

5. Overtime Regulations

In 2016, the United States Department of Labor issued a Final Rule making sweeping changes to the regulations regarding minimum wage and overtime. 80 FR 38515, July 6, 2015. The Final Rule substantially increased the minimum salary amount an employer must pay to qualify for the most common exemptions to the overtime pay obligation, from $455 per week to $913 per week.

In November 2016, however, a federal district judge in Texas issued a nationwide injunction precluding implementation of the Final Rule. Although the Obama administration appealed, it is unlikely that the Trump administration will pursue the appeal. Thus, the Final Rule likely will not go into effect.

6. EEOC Wellness Program Regulations

Employer wellness plans have grown in popularity over the years. These programs are geared toward disease prevention and health promotion. Employers usually offer these programs as part of an employer-sponsored group health plan or separately as a benefit of employment. Many of these programs ask employees to answer questions on a health risk assessment or undergo screenings for high blood pressure or cholesterol. Other wellness program features may include nutrition classes, weight loss and smoking cessation programs, onsite exercise facilities, and/or coaching to help employees meet health goals. Employers offer incentives to employees for participating in wellness programs, such as discounted health insurance premiums and gift cards.

Wellness programs have laudable goals, but they raise concerns under federal laws concerning medical privacy such as the Americans with Disabilities Act and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act. These laws generally prohibit employer medical inquiries unless for specific, statutory purposes. Many employees with medical problems and work injuries have legitimate concerns that whatever they disclose will be used against them.

The EEOC issued regulations in May 2016 to balance the risks of employers’ use of wellness programs with the benefits of such programs. 81 FR 31125, May 17, 2016. The regulations limit the incentives that employers may provide to employees for participation (to make participation truly voluntary), prohibit retaliation against employees who refuse to participate in such programs, and otherwise provide a roadmap for employers who wish to implement wellness programs without violating the ADA. There have been numerous legal challenges to the wellness program regulations and some courts have refused to give them any deference. Nevertheless, the regulations and annotations provide a good starting point for researching this issue.

2017 is likely to bring changes, and nothing is written in stone. Rest assured that we will stay on top of federal law issues for our membership.